Resistance to bribery when aggregating soft constraints
نویسندگان
چکیده
We consider a multi-agent scenario, where the preferences of several agents are modelled via soft constraint problems and need to be aggregated to compute a single ”socially optimal” solution. We study the resistance of various ways to compute such a solution to influence the result, such as those based on the notion of bribery. In doing this, we link the cost of bribing an agent to the effort needed by the agent to make a certain solution optimal, by only changing preferences associated to parts of the solution. This leads to the definition of four notions of distance from optimality of a solution in a soft constraint problem. The notions differ on the amount of information considered when evaluating the effort.
منابع مشابه
Bribery in Voting With Soft Constraints
We consider a multi-agent scenario where a collection of agents needs to select a common decision from a large set of decisions over which they express their preferences. This decision set has a combinatorial structure, that is, each decision is an element of the Cartesian product of the domains of some variables. Agents express their preferences over the decisions via soft constraints. We cons...
متن کاملA Framework for Aggregating Influenced CP-Nets and its Resistance to Bribery
We consider multi-agent settings where a set of agents want to take a collective decision, based on their preferences over the possible candidate options. While agents have their initial inclination, they may interact and influence each other, and therefore modify their preferences, until hopefully they reach a stable state and declare their final inclination. At that point, a voting rule is us...
متن کاملConstraint satisfaction using soft quantifiers
Ronald R. Yager Machine Intelligence Institute, Iona College New Rochelle, NY 10801 [email protected] (212)249-2047 ABSTRACT Fuzzy sets and other methods have been used to model a softening of constraints in CP problems. Here we suggest an approach to the softening of the CP problem at the meta level, the process used to aggregate the satisfactions to the individual constraints. We suggest the us...
متن کاملDoes bribery help or hurt firm growth around the world?
Does bribery help or hurt firm growth? Some suggest that bribery greases the wheel of commerce, while others believe that bribery sands the wheel of growth. We argue that firms endogenously choose their level of bribery according to their environments and that the benefits and costs may differ for different types of bribery. Specifically, small firms are more likely to be forced to engage in br...
متن کاملرشوه در زمان توقف حق بر آن
From the viewpoint of some experts in Sharia law, paying bribes in lawsuits by the beneficiary is lawful. Some others believe that this permission is only possible when obtaining the right is restricted to paying the bribe. Various reasons, including Islamic traditions Hadiths[, the rule of denial of hardship, and the permission to obtain the right are the evidences for this verdict. Studies sh...
متن کامل